Unlocking your cellphone now illegal in US


Asof this past weekend itis now a violation of federal law to unlock your cellphone without your carriers consent.

For a few brief years it was legal to do so, but this rule change, at the hands of the Librarian of Congress, is the result of a review of the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act).

There has been a lot of outrage about this change to the law. But really, I largely fail to see why.

Originally the right to unlock ones cellphone was allowed because really, consumers had little if any options to buy one unlocked. But that is no longer the case. Even the top phones, such as Apples Iphone Google Nexus 4. SamsungGalaxy etc can be purchased unlocked.  Indeed, a quick search at electronics box store Best Buy reveals close to 100 unlocked phones available- including a large selection of high end smartphones.

And let’s face it- the cellular market in the US operates differently then much of the world. Most people buy a heavily subsidized phone from a carrier, which the carrier then makes bac (and then some) the subsidy over the 2 year contract one agrees to. (for example- the Iphone can be had for around $200 with a 2 year contract, while the cost without a contract is around $650.

So obviously carriers don’t want to give you a phone for less then 1/3 of the cost and then have you stop paying your bill and move the phone to another carrier. And most carriers will temporarily unlock your under contract phone for you if you plan to be travelling.

And of course, the law only applies to new cellphones purchased under contract. So if you buy one or are given one whether new or used you can legally unlock it. (caveat: that’s assuming it wasn’t stolen or was purchased under contract since the law goes into effect and still has contract remaining on it).

Best summary of the situation I’ve found here.

While I have some reservations with the laws swirling around this issue (such as the 9th circuit ruling we “rent” the software on these phones rather then own them), as well as some carriers policies that make buying out the contract unfair (ie: you get a subsidized phone on a carrier- move to an area where there service is horrible, and have to pay far more to end the contract then if you had just bought an unlocked phone)…in general it seems to me much of the whining has been from people that either don’t understand the law, or who want something for nothing- essentially want a carrier to give them a loan to buy the phone and then have the freedom to walk away without repaying that loan.

Advertisements

About drugsandotherthings

I am a criminal. Because I have used cannabis and psychedelics extensively. I have tried many other drugs, but never cared for the uppers, downers, or dissociatives. I love craft beer, and absinthe, but don't care much for alcohols effects- which quite frankly, are boring and dangerous. Science is my religion. I am in my 40's, and have travelled extensively. And often forced myself outside of my confort zone. I am employed, a respected member of my communtiy, an animal lover, an environmentalist, a political junkie, and the realities I have experienced continue to push me further to the left of the political spectrum.
This entry was posted in social, Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Unlocking your cellphone now illegal in US

  1. Denise Lee says:

    i don’t believe a large percentage of people unlock to switch ~ certainly not enough to make this drastic change that affects and punishes all phone subscribers!

    If this illegal issue bothers you, and you want to have the option to be able to unlock a device you believe you paid for and own, then sign this official Petition and pass it along:
    https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/make-unlocking-cell-phones-legal/1g9KhZG7

    There’s still time! 12 days left to get 100,000 minimum signatures.. At present, there is 60,000 sigs.. Please pass this petition link around to help make a difference!

    • May I ask then WHY you think people “unlock” if not to switch carriers?

      To be clear- this is differnt from jailbreaking. And all carriers offer options for temprary unlocking for those who travel- especially internationally.

      Iam really at a loss as to how this “punishes” anyone. As I quite clearly point out- and as quite clearly stated in the reasoning for this switch- unlocked phones are quite readibly available to any and all that want them- they simply are not subsidized by the carrier in exchange for a 2 year commitment to recoup the costs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s